Vortex generators (or VGs) are small aerodynamic devices that enhance the performance of aircraft, wind turbines, and even some ground vehicles.
When they energize the boundary layer and delay flow separation, they help improve the lift, control response and stall characteristics.
Want to know more? Let's explore how vortex generators work.
SUMMARY
-
Vortex generators create mini vortices that re-energize the boundary layer, delaying stall and improving control surface effectiveness.
-
They are used on both low-speed STOL aircraft and high-speed transonic aircraft to prevent flow separation.
-
VGs can be found on airliner wings, in front of flaps, and on horizontal stabilizers for stable airflow.
-
Aftermarket VG kits for general aviation aircraft can reduce stall speeds and improve safety, though they may slightly reduce cruise speed.
What Are Vortex Generators?
So, what are they? Vortex generators are small vanes or fins mounted on an aircraft’s wing, fuselage, or control surfaces.
The vortex generator was designed to create controlled vortices. These are mixed with high-energy free-stream air with slower-moving air in the boundary layer. The point of this is to prevent flow separation and improves aerodynamic performance.
Aircraft manufacturers install VGs to enhance stability, control, and stall resistance. While they are common on commercial and military aircraft. They are also found on general aviation and STOL aircraft for improving low-speed handling characteristics.
How Do Vortex Generators Work?
How they work is that the vortex generators function by creating mini wingtip vortices. These vortices help prevent flow separation by pulling high-energy air into the boundary layer, maintaining attached airflow over the surface.
When the air moves over the airfoil, the pressure decreases until it reaches the center of lift. Beyond this point, the pressure increases, and it creates an adverse pressure gradient. The gradient causes airflow to slow down and separate, leading to an aerodynamic stall.
VGs can mitigate this effect by energizing the boundary layer, it makes sure that the airflow can withstand the pressure gradient longer. That allows the wings and control surfaces to still work well at high angles of attack to improve the aircraft's stability and control.
Vortex Generators in STOL and General Aviation Aircraft
Now, STOL (Short Takeoff and Landing) aircraft benefit quite a bit from vortex generators. They are installed on the leading edge of the wing, and they allow for lower stall speeds and improved takeoff and landing performance.
Many general aviation pilots install aftermarket VG kits or micro vortex generators to get these advantages. These kits help to improve the controllability by enhancing the usage of the aileron, elevator, and rudder, especially at low speeds.
Some kits even permit an increase in maximum takeoff weight due to reduced stall speeds and improved climb performance.
One thing to note is that installing VGs can slightly decrease the cruise speed because of the added drag. Tests on aircraft like the Cessna 182 and Piper PA-28 Cherokee showed minor reductions in the cruising speed (1.5 to 2 knots), but this is often a worthwhile tradeoff for improved low-speed handling.
Vortex Generators on Airliners
When it comes to commercial airliners, vortex generators are usually found ahead of flaps and other high-lift devices. These locations can have adverse pressure gradients, and that can lead to flow separation during takeoff and landing.
VGs improve the adequacy of high-lift systems by preventing separation, this lets airflow over the wings and advances the control responsiveness.
VGs also can help with noise reduction, like with aircraft such as the Airbus A320, where VGs help to minimize the sound generated by airflow over fuel tank pressure equalization vents.
Vortex Generators in Transonic and Supersonic Flight
At high speeds, aircraft experience compressibility effects that cause to the formation of shock waves. These shock waves can cause abrupt airflow separation behind control surfaces potentially leading to control issues.
The way this is countered is that the vortex generators are placed strategically on wings and horizontal stabilizers to keep airflow attached.
For example, the L-39 Albatros trainer uses VGs on its stabilizer to prevent transonic flow separation and to maintain the pitch control at high speeds.
How Vortex Generators Increase Maximum Takeoff Weight
With twin-engine aircraft, VGs can lead to an increase in maximum takeoff weight (MTOW). Because they lower stall speed, the one-engine-inoperative climb performance requirement is reduced. This creates a higher allowable MTOW.
Keep in mind that VGs do not usually increase maximum landing weight. That is determined by structural limits rather than stall speed considerations.
Pilots have to manage fuel consumption to make sure that they do not exceed landing weight restrictions when returning from a long flight.
Are There Downsides to Vortex Generators?
VGs offer many benefits, but there are some trade-offs:
-
Slight Reduction in Cruise Speed: Added drag can result in minor speed losses, though typically only 1-2 knots.
-
Icing and Maintenance Considerations: VGs generally reside within the boundary layer and are not prone to in-flight icing, but they can make it harder to remove ice and snow from the wings when on the ground.
-
Potential for Fabric Damage: VGs may have sharp edges that can damage aircraft covers, so they might need specialized coverings to prevent wear and tear.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Do vortex generators really lower stall speed?
Yes, a vortex generator can delay flow separation, allowing the wing to maintain lift at lower airspeeds, effectively reducing stall speed.
-
Will installing VGs on my aircraft reduce cruise speed?
There may be a slight reduction (1.5-2 knots), but the improved low-speed handling and safety benefits often outweigh this drawback.
-
Can a vortex generator increase takeoff weight?
On some twin-engine aircraft, they can increase MTOW by reducing stall speed and improving single-engine climb performance.
-
Are vortex generators difficult to install?
For homebuilt and experimental aircraft, they are relatively easy to install. But certified aircraft require FAA approval, which can add costs.
-
Do airliners use vortex generators?
Yes, they are commonly found ahead of flaps and control surfaces to maintain airflow attachment during takeoff and landing.
-
Can vortex generators help with high-speed control issues?
Yes, they prevent airflow separation at transonic speeds, keeping the control wing surface effective.
-
What are the advantages of micro vortex generators?
Micro vortex generators improve airflow control with less drag, enhancing stall prevention, fuel efficiency, and high-speed stability while being lightweight and easy to install.
-
Where should vortex generators be placed?
Place vortex generators where airflow separation happens—near the wing’s leading edge, in front of flaps, on stabilizers, or around engine intakes.
-
Can you attach vortex generators to wind turbine blades?
Yes. Vortex generators on wind turbine blades help by reducing drag, improving lift, and increasing power output. They much sure the air flows smoothly and they help turbines perform better at all speeds.
Takeaway
Vortex generators are a small and simple aerodynamic enhancement used across many types of aircraft.
On a Cessna 182, a Boeing 737, or a transonic military jet, VGs help maintain control, delay stalls, and can help to improve the overall flight characteristics. And yes, they come with some trade-offs, but their benefits far outweigh the drawbacks.
Interested in Aircrafts?
Our guides are designed to help!
-
Technically Advanced Aircraft - Helping Shape Modern Aviation
-
Aircraft Stability: 3 Types of Static + Dynamic Aircraft Stability
-
Composite Aircraft: 4 Popular Composite Aircraft Built to Date
-
Aircraft Wing Design: 10 Types of Aircraft Wings (Complete Guide)
Did you find this article helpful?
Do you think we missed an important interview question? Let us know in the comments below!
